by azbackpackr » Jan 06 2007 7:42 am
About Death in Grand Canyon. I actually have a postcard with the cover of that book as its picture and on the back a very nice note from the author, Michael Ghiglieri, who was kind enough to respond to a letter I sent him. His other books I've read are Canyon and First Through Grand Canyon.
Everyone who hikes or rafts the Canyon who has read Powell's account should also read First Through Grand Canyon. It is probably as close to the truth of what really happened on Powell's first expedition as you are going to find anywhere. You guys do know that Powell told numerous lies about that 1869 expedition? He is one of those people that, while I can admire his intrepid courage, I don't really like him. As a human being he left much to be desired. What happened to the Howland brothers and William Dunn after they left the party at Separation Rapids? Why did Powell combine events from both expeditions into one account, making it sound like it was one expedition, and leaving out the names of the people in the second expedtion, such as Frederick Dellenbaugh, who himself was a very prominent person of the day? Why did he never even pay his hired boatmen?
Information about what really happened to Dunn and the Howlands is kept hidden away somewhere in Utah. The historian from Tucson who found direct evidence that these three men were killed by settlers, not Indians, was told he could no longer look at the letters he had been reading, where they were kept in a library. Here it is, now almost 140 years later, and they are hiding the evidence from the historians. But the boatmen on the expedition kept secret diaries, and were suspicious of events afterward, so even without these sequestered letters it is pretty clear what actually happened to those guys.
While I'm on the topic, if you can find Down the Colorado, by Robert B. Stanton, then it's a definite "must" on your reading list if you are studying Grand Canyon history. Stanton was an engineer on the ill-fated 1889 expedition to build a railroad down the Canyon below the rim. In addition to being a gripping tale of tragedy and disaster, Stanton truly saw the beauty of the Canyon and could express it in words. It's a great story, and it should be reprinted. I do not own a copy, having found it in the Tucson Pima library system, the U of A library, and also through interlibrary loan. Every time I try to find a copy on Amazon it is not to be found. There is another book he wrote I haven't read yet: Colorado River Controversies, where he really rips Powell.
Also, if you have been to South Canyon or Vasey's Paradise, then you probably climbed up to Stanton's Cave, where the party stayed after one of the several tragedies.
[/i]