If a shuttle is a possibility, you might try Peralta T/H to Canyon Lake T/H. in the Sup's.
As well, Rogers Cyn. then Frog Tanks around to Reavis Ranch, then back out the Reavis Trail to the Rogers T/H is nice, as well. ( an added bonus is that you could visit Circlestone on this loop)
Or, from Peralta T/H, take the Dutchman trail to Miners' Summit, picking up the Whiskey Sp. Trail, to the Red Tanks Tr. north & you will again pickup the Dutchman Tr. near LaBarge Spring.
If you continue north you can hit Charlebois sp., then head west on the Dutchman, and either take the Terapin, Dutchman or Peralta back to the T/H.
You might consider buying, or checking out @ the library The "Hikers Guide to the Superstition Wilderness" by Jack Carlson & Elizabeth Stewart.
Have fun !