Page 1 of 3
Mindless competition
Posted: Oct 29 2012 8:05 am
by SAMBA
I'm fine with the antennas, antennae for my non-American brethren (
http://grammarist.com/usage/antennae-antennas/); my objection is with those who MINDLESSLY seek out the peaks in the first place. The notion that "bagging" a peak is a worthwhile endeavor just "because it's there" is INSANE. I could care less whether or not they've bagged the Colorado 14ers, or any other arbitrarily compiled list, for that matter. That said, I might be persuaded to temper my "peak bagging" rant, if there's anybody out there in HAZ land who has "bagged" the Colorado 13ers who objects to my comments. BTW (computerese for "By The Way"), when did hiking transition from a recreational pursuit to some goal driven compulsion?
Re: Thompson Peak Summit: How hazardous are the ...
Posted: Oct 29 2012 9:43 am
by Sredfield
Whatever floats the boat, if someone wants to work against a list --14's, AZT, PCT, State High Points, etc. -- what does anyone care. The big draw of hiking is "hike your own hike," whatever that is.
Re: Thompson Peak Summit: How hazardous are the ...
Posted: Oct 29 2012 10:48 am
by BobP
SAMBA wrote:when did hiking transition from a recreational pursuit to some goal driven compulsion?
Ohhh. that reminds me I still need to do a hike starting with an X.
Re: Thompson Peak Summit: How hazardous are the ...
Posted: Oct 29 2012 11:25 am
by big_load
rlrjamy wrote:Ohhh. that reminds me I still need to do a hike starting with an X.
You can scratch an "X" into the dust at the TH. It would be sort of like Winnie the Pooh living under the name of Sanders (literally).
Re: Thompson Peak Summit: How hazardous are the ...
Posted: Oct 29 2012 11:43 am
by chumley
SAMBA wrote:BTW (computerese for "By The Way"), when did hiking transition from a recreational pursuit to some goal driven compulsion?
Pursuit? What is being pursued if there's no goal?
http://hikearizona.com/x.php?I=9.9
691!

Re: Thompson Peak Summit: How hazardous are the ...
Posted: Oct 29 2012 12:11 pm
by SAMBA
chumley wrote:SAMBA wrote:BTW (computerese for "By The Way"), when did hiking transition from a recreational pursuit to some goal driven compulsion?
Pursuit? What is being pursued if there's no goal?
http://hikearizona.com/x.php?I=9.9
691!

Fun? Would it be heretical in this distinguished forum to suggest that hiking for the sake of hiking can be FUN?
Re: Thompson Peak Summit: How hazardous are the ...
Posted: Oct 29 2012 12:26 pm
by SAMBA
big_load wrote:rlrjamy wrote:Ohhh. that reminds me I still need to do a hike starting with an X.
You can scratch an "X" into the dust at the TH. It would be sort of like Winnie the Pooh living under the name of Sanders (literally).
Why bother? Vape, et.al. have already saved you the effort of scratching an "X",
http://hikearizona.com/decoder.php?ZTN=15334.
Re: Mindless competition
Posted: Oct 29 2012 12:40 pm
by PLC92084
SAMBA wrote:when did hiking transition from a recreational pursuit to some goal driven compulsion
Sadly... I've hiked with more than a few folks who seem to have OCD when it comes to peaks. And almost all, without fail, have asked if I've hiked (or will be hiking) Whitney (as if that's the be-all, end-all to achieve hiking bliss in CA)...

Re: Mindless competition
Posted: Oct 29 2012 12:56 pm
by PatrickL
Peakbagging for me is a gateway to new places, as well as a way to challenge myself with more difficult hikes. My most difficult hikes have been entirely centered around peaks, and all of those peaks are located in places that I can't wait to visit again.
We all get different highs from different things, whether it's biking to various bars around Tucson, or standing atop the highest peaks. There's no reason for anyone to rant.
Re: Mindless competition
Posted: Oct 29 2012 12:57 pm
by The_Eagle
Patrick L wrote:We all get different highs from different things, whether it's biking to various bars around Tucson,

Re: Mindless competition
Posted: Oct 29 2012 1:02 pm
by PatrickL
Just for the record, I enjoyed those photosets.
Re: Mindless competition
Posted: Oct 29 2012 1:05 pm
by The_Eagle
rlrjamy wrote:Ohhh. that reminds me I still need to do a hike starting with an X.
X and Z for me..... :bdh:
Re: Mindless competition
Posted: Oct 29 2012 1:38 pm
by big_load
I go for the experience and view. I've hiked some 13ers and 14ers, but I don't have any specific list-based goals nor do I care what anyone thinks about what I have or haven't hiked.
Re: Thompson Peak Summit: How hazardous are the ...
Posted: Oct 29 2012 1:40 pm
by CannondaleKid
SAMBA wrote:Fun? Would it be heretical in this distinguished forum to suggest that hiking for the sake of hiking can be FUN?
Do you believe it's beyond the realm of possibility for people to actually ENJOY hiking
with a goal in mind? If it takes a goal to get someone out hiking, I say WONDERFUL, at least they are out hiking!
Personally, I can say I thoroughly enjoy hiking whether I'm hiking a trail I've done numerous times, wandering completely off in the wilderness with no particular destination in mind, or yes, even when (heaven forbid)
bagging a peak.
I'm curious why you feel bagging a peak for any reason is considered insane. Yes, most of my hikes are 'peak baggers' but guess what? Who cares... While it may be a well-worn cliche,
'It isn't the destination but the journey' fits me perfectly. I do it for the exhilaration I get just by hiking to someplace I haven't been before. Besides, I think it's a lot more fun to choose a specific destination (peak, spring, mine, canyon, whatever) than to pick a random set of coordinates to hike to.
That brings to mind, how do you choose which bar to bike to? Oh... right... biking for biking's sake IS the fun, not the destination.
Oh, by the way (yes, I can actually write the words), I don't hold your choice of destination against you, I'd only ask the same in return... and for all of us who hike with a destination in mind. Thanks, I'd appreciate it!
I've said my piece... someone else can have their turn on the :SB:
Re: Mindless competition
Posted: Oct 29 2012 1:43 pm
by chumley
big_load wrote:I go for the experience and view. I've hiked some 13ers and 14ers, but I don't have any specific list-based goals nor do I care what anyone thinks about what I have or haven't hiked.
Not me. I only hike for the recognition I get from other people. I actually hate hiking. But I need people to "like" my comments, triplogs, and photosets. Hiking is only a means to that end. Please like this comment so I can sleep peacefully tonight. Thanks.
Re: Mindless competition
Posted: Oct 29 2012 1:47 pm
by The_Eagle
@chumley
Like, Like, Like, Like, Like, Like, Like, Like, Like
Re: Mindless competition
Posted: Oct 29 2012 1:49 pm
by SAMBA
coanbru wrote:Patrick L wrote:We all get different highs from different things, whether it's biking to various bars around Tucson,

My efforts in "bagging" bars in Tucson had nothing to do with knocking something new off of an arbitrary list. I was simply doing HOMEWORK. As a matter of fact, I may be re-visiting one or two of those welcoming watering holes when I complete this afternoon's political canvassing.
Re: Mindless competition
Posted: Oct 29 2012 1:56 pm
by CannondaleKid
chumley wrote:Not me. I only hike for the recognition I get from other people. I actually hate hiking. But I need people to "like" my comments, triplogs, and photosets. Hiking is only a means to that end. Please like this comment so I can sleep peacefully tonight. Thanks.
Just for the record, I detest Facebook and the whole thing about 'Liking', but I'll be doggoned if I don't LOVE this post! :worthy:
(How come there's no 'thumbs-up' smiley?)
Ok, chumley, I 'liked' your post but don't expect me to like anything else, whether it be triplog, photoset, or whatever. ;)
Re: Mindless competition
Posted: Oct 29 2012 2:01 pm
by SAMBA
I guess it's time for me end this discussion with this one question. Have you ever hiked in Utah? There is no better hiking in the whole world than in Utah, and that statement is incontrovertible. But there are no peaks in Utah south of I-70, yet Utah hiking is the BEST.
Re: Mindless competition
Posted: Oct 29 2012 2:16 pm
by cindyl
SAMBA wrote:As a matter of fact, I may be re-visiting one or two of those welcoming watering holes when I complete this afternoon's political canvassing.
i might see you at one of those watering holes tonight. if so, i'd love to discuss this more. i love peak bagging, i get such an adrenaline rush and a personal sense of accomplishment and empowerment (not to mention, i save my peak beers for the tops of peaks to give me an added insentive). i'm not after being on the top of any list for mileage or aeg, but i get a kick out of knowing what i've done, and trying to accomplish my personal best. i also like peaks since for the most part, once you've made it to the top, all the hard work is done and it's an easy downhill back to the post-hike libation. (jeez - re-reading that i understand where i got my kopelli). cheers!