Great with water!!
This loop clocked at 17.82 miles on my GPS odometer. It is long and strenuous involving 5 trails which I did in February 2008 after some large rainfalls that left plenty of water in the creeks and streams in the Superstitions. I started the hike from the Peters Trailhead and went clockwise first over the road a short distance (0.18 miles) to the JF Trailhead and then making all right turns onto the JF Trail (0.77 miles), Hoolie Bacon (4.70 miles), Red Tanks (3.75 miles), Dutchman Trail (1.12 miles) and Peters Trail (7.30 miles).
You can either park at the trailhead off route 88 and add 6.5 miles to the hike or drive to the Peters or JF trailheads (3.25 miles) over a road that definitely requires a 4WD high clearance vehicle. I drove and parked at the Peters trailhead in my stock 2005 4Runner the night before the hike and started hiking at day break a few minutes before 7:00 AM. The 4Runner handled the road well going at a snail's pace over some of the larger rocks there. I did earn some Arizona pin stripes on washed out parts of that road. I would have no hesitation driving out there again.
Parts of this hike rate highly and parts not so high. I would rate the first mile over the road and JF trails a 1, the entire Hoolie Bacon trail a 2, the first 1.5 miles of the Red Tanks through the Upper LaBarge box is a 4 when there is large amounts of water and a 3 when it is dry, the remaining 2.25 miles of the Red Tanks and the 1.12 miles of the Ducthmans rates a 3 with lots of water and a 2 when dry. The Peters trail provides great down canyon views as it climbs off of the Dutchmans trail and descends back to the Peters trailhead and rates a 3 in my opinion.
There were many stream crossings along the way. My boots were capable of handling 2 to 3 inches of water which I did on a couple of crossings so my socks remained dry. A little more rain, unusual as it may be, and some of the crossings would be wet.
Because you pass very near Charlebois spring, the most reliable water source in the Superstitions, it would always be possible to backpack for a one nighter camping there while doing this loop. I finished at 5:45 PM and was back on route 88 just before dark. Another great hiking day!!
WARNING! Hiking and outdoor related sports can be dangerous. Be responsible and prepare for the trip. Study the area you are entering and plan accordingly. Dress for the current and unexpected weather changes. Take plenty of water. Never go alone. Make an itinerary with your plan(s), route(s), destination(s) and expected return time. Give your itinerary to trusted family and/or friends.