Canyons are inherently risky. Flash floods occur without notice on sunny days. Technical skills & surrounding topography knowledge required yet does not eliminate risk.
This South fork drainage was one of the last canyons in the Alamogordo area that I had scheduled for exploring, and having had various glimpses over and down into the cut from the adjoining ridge, I was hoping for great things. I have been pleasantly surprised time and again with the other area canyons that did not seem to have much potential; this day began with High Hopes!
I guess it is a good thing to have our expectations knocked down now and again.
It was not a bad canyon. If there were no other canyon cuts in the area, and/or the other canyons were not so great, then perhaps I'd have a different feeling about this drainage. It did have some rock slabbing. It had some pleasant falls. There were a couple of challenging climb/scrambles. It did not have any of the towering side canyon rock walls. The vistas were mostly less than. It continually returned to overgrown narrows with too much sidewall gravel. There was nothing overly difficult about the hike; maybe that is part of the problem?
I did note that looping down through it's sister canyon, Lost Trail Canyon, North, that I was once again enjoying that pleasant mix of rock, plants and views in a balance that restored my day. That seemed to be missing over in the south fork.
The hike begins right in town at the city water tank. Dropping into the drainage you walk the first rocky, gravelly mile past the houses on the adjoining ridge to your right. You pass the cut on your right up into Ortega Canyon (...now, that's a nice canyon!) and move up to the slick rock waterfall coming in on your left. This is the real beginning of the South Fork. Up and over the waterfall would carry you up the North Fork. Instead, you turn right and follow the scrubby drainage east. At about 1.5 miles into the hike you will come to a fork. The minor canyon to your left is too overgrown to enjoy going too far up into, but there is a nice breakfast rock shelf about 50 yds up canyon if you want to check it out. Your real path is to the right.
Around 2.5 miles into the hike, the canyon splits once again. The left fork cliffs out shortly after the fork, but it does include a series of nice rock slab shelving to check out. The main canyon moves to the right up a series of boulders and small falls... still overgrown. There is a touch of interesting climbing/scrambling to top out the falls there.
Finally, around 3 miles into the hike, once again the canyon splits with the right fork again providing the better route to the top. This time you will work your way up and around a blocked off dirt/gravel spill over (easy on the left) then confront a 60' cliffed out falls. You can scramble up the right side, or take the more challenging slot cut on the left side; or some combination thereof?
The hike is about over at this point. As you move off above the falls, angle to the left (north) and finally exit the bottom and climb up the low ridge to your left, intersecting the Dry Canyon/Ortega Traverse trail.
From this point you have a very easy and much nicer hike down to Lost Trail, following it to Lost Trail Canyon: North Fork... which you can follow down and right back to your car. Or... follow the Traverse trail south to connect with T119, following that steep route down. It will take you to within .3 mile of where you parked.
So... it was nice enough to do again, but no time soon. Enough time needs to pass to forget that it is not really all it could/should be. If I had hiked this one before I'd discovered all those other... nicer... canyons...??
Oh, well... High Hopes.
WARNING! Hiking and outdoor related sports can be dangerous. Be responsible and prepare for the trip. Study the area you are entering and plan accordingly. Dress for the current and unexpected weather changes. Take plenty of water. Never go alone. Make an itinerary with your plan(s), route(s), destination(s) and expected return time. Give your itinerary to trusted family and/or friends.