This trail has received a lot of maintenance since the Willow Fire in 2004. It's still difficult to follow in areas. Avid hikers will like it, casual hiker will probably turn around.Hike
Deer Creek Trail (#45) reminded me of both the Barnhardt trail (a few miles north) and Secret Mountain trail in Sedona. Barnhardt (BH) has well paced and fairly uniform elevation gain (at least for my tastes) and provides an excellent sampling of all the Arizona terra zones (high desert scrub up to pines). Deer Creek (DC) starts similarly but has a much more modest elevation gain (at least for the first 4 miles or so.all the time I had that day). DC does have, however, high desert, nice sections of riparian growth (cottonwood and sycamore trees, river grasses, ivy), a gurgling creek, grave site (!), and working windmill powered water pump. I thought it was worth doing at least once.
If I had to choose only one, I'd go with BH, but I decided to check out DC since I've already done BH a few times and DC is closer to the valley. The trailhead is literally a stone's throw from highway 87. The turnoff to the trailhead is well marked from SR 87, right at the highway 87/188 juncture (where the rest stop is.rougly highway marker 235.5). Coming from the valley, this is a big plus in travel time and wear/tear to your wheels compared to BH, which has a 5.5 mile rutted, washboardy dirt (sometimes muddy) road you must take to get to the trailhead. Probably saved an hour round trip. It's a minus if highway noise bothers you (I only noticed the first 1/2 mile or so).
I hiked on May 27, 2001 (Memorial weekend), and it wasn't a cool day by any means. Luckily there are sections of shade throughout (some pretty dense), and the trail more or less runs along the north side of a ridge/canyon, so going in you've got ridge/shrub/trees rising to your left, creek to your right. I'd guess that in March/April the sun is low enough in the sky that you're mostly in the shade once you're in the creek area. No other humans in sight on this trail.half dozen cottontails, a harmless water snake, and probably 1,000+ lizards. No deer!
Like BH, it's got that funky mix of desert cactus type veg, mixed with high desert scrub, and oddly colored rock.deep purple, red, green, blue, etc. Prickly pear cactus was in bloom, as were a few blooms of some orange wildflower looking stuff near the creek. You're introduced to the creek after about 3/4 of a mile. Around this area, reach into your pack and pull out any horses you brought (ha ha) to give them a drink from the windmill powered water pump that trickles water into a metal trough.
From there the trail alternates back and forth from being creekside, to only being within earshot/view; brief sections of up/down over natural land contours. At the approx 1.5 to 2 mile mark you'll find a single grave site.'David O. Cowan, 1843-1926'. At the approx 3 1/4 miles you 'officially' enter the Mazatzal Wilderness (a forestry sign tips you off). At this point you're heading back creekside, actually crossing it several times (I think the full hike involves about 20 creek crossings after this point). Water level was maybe ankle high.no big deal. The terrain was really just getting interesting about this point, but had to turn back. Eventually it climbs into pine country. It's 8.8 miles one way to FR201 and numerous connecting trails.
It would be worth returning after a good rain when everything is wet and it's overcast.good photo opportunities. On my particular trip there was only some high diffuse clouds, so most pics ended up washed out.