This 6.5 mile loop hike starts off from the Woodbury Trailhead and heads out the Coffee Flat Trail to the junction of Fraser and Whetrock canyons. The return trip up Whetrock Canyon is an off trail adventure leading to a couple of mines before exiting onto an old Forest Service Road for the return to the trailhead. The hike is best described in Carlson's "Hiker's Guide to the Superstition Wilderness" under trip #51.
Carolyn and I set out on a beautiful Saturday morning on January 29th at 10:00 with the temperatures in the mid 60's. Rather than park at the Woodbury Trailhead itself, we parked a little ways up the road from the Woodbury turnoff right next to the gate blocking the road to the JF Ranch. This parking selection probably shaved off 1/2 mile of road hiking from the loop. We were expecting this 6.5 mile hike, (now closer to 6 miles), to be a 3+ hour "cupcake" with the biggest challenge being some potential creek bed "boulder hopping" in Whetrock Canyon. Once again, I underestimated the Superstitions. (smile)
Initially, this hike is nothing spectacular as one is merely hiking the road to the JF Ranch. As one approaches the ranch, the gate for the signed Coffee Flat Trail is just to the north, (hiker's right), along the fence line. It's pretty much just open desert grazing country until one gets west of the ranch and into Fraser Canyon. Water was running in the stream bed but it was nothing to skirt and remain feet dry on the numerous wash crossings. Just before the entrance to Whetrock Canyon, the trail climbs up the north side of Fraser Canyon 100 feet or so before dropping back down to the creek bed. The entrance to Whetrock Canyon itself is really cool and just under an hour into the hike. This entrance is a recessed narrow crack in the rock wall on the southern side of the creek bed that one could easily walk right past if you weren't looking for it. For the first 50 feet, this passage is no more than 6 to 10 feet wide. On this particular day, due to the recent rains, it was impassable as there were several thigh deep pools with no "safe" or dry way around them. (This was to be a harbinger of things to come.) We elected to back track a few yards down Fraser Canyon and scramble over the top and drop back down into Whetrock Canyon. However, once we got up on top, we elected to stay up on the bench as the creek bed below was full of water and brush. In Carlson's book, they recommend staying up high on the east side of the canyon and to follow the cow paths. While we found no sign of a cow path or any kind of path for that matter, it was relatively clear and easy going. We eventually dropped back down into the creek bed and followed it until either water or brush, (or both), made it impassable. It was then a scramble up the sides of the creek bed. The entire trip up Whetrock Canyon became a bushwhack as there is no trail. We simply took the course of least resistance which alternated between the creek bed and the bench above it, usually on the east side.
After about a 1/2 to 3/4 mile trek, one can see the upper mine's tailings way at the canyon's end. It turns out that this is the hike's exit out of Whetrock Canyon. Further up the canyon, the creek bed becomes more of a steep ravine. (On the topo map, this occurs shortly after the "n" in canyon.) Once we got down in the bottom of this ravine, we lost sight of the upper mine tailings which represented our bearing line. We knew we were on track when we came across the remains of the old dairy truck. This is where we made our first mistake. We continued up the relatively clear drainage containing the dairy truck thinking that it would eventually lead to the old "road" servicing the mines. How else would the dairy truck get to where it was? However, this drainage wound around and was taking us too far north from our bearing line. After a short while, this drainage became impassable due to the undergrowth. It was at this point that Carolyn suggested backtracking to the dairy truck and looking for another way, which she did. I scrambled up the drainage, (ie: hikers right), and stumbled upon the tailings of the first, (ie: the lower), mine. I yelled down to Carolyn and she ended up back tracking about 30 yards past the dairy truck and came around and up the other drainage to the right. From there it was a much easier scramble up to where I was at the lower mine. (Carlson's book suggest scrambling directly up the slope above the dairy truck which would work too, but Carolyn's way was easier I think.) There's an old refrigerator and cement trough just to the right of these tailings. The mine entrance itself has been closed off with a dirt cave in.
This is where we made out second mistake. From this lower mine, we could make out the remains of a faint road heading down and across the drainage to the south, (hiker's right), and heading up a ridge. We went this way as we thought, incorrectly, that this was the former mine road providing our exit. Once we climbed up the ridge on the other side we saw the error of our ways. From this higher vantage point, we could make out the tailings of the upper mine and, more importantly, what appeared to be a "road" winding up the slope between the upper and lower mine. Once again at Carolyn's urging, we headed back to the lower mine and found this "road" climbing out in a northerly direction. While we were resting at the lower mine, we heard the rumble of ATVs above us and could make a few riders above the upper tailings. (Apparently they disregarded the "No Motor Vehicles" sign at the Wilderness Boundary which is around the corner from the upper mine.) At it's beginning at the lower mine, the "road" is nothing more than a path clear of trees & scrub brush and covered in rocks and grass which even ATVs would have difficulty negotiating. It is this grass that outlined the path and made it visible from across the canyon. The path then cut back across the face of the slope before switching back in front of the upper mine. The further up we climbed, the more distinct this path became. When we got to the upper mine entrance, the path resembled a narrow road and was covered in ATV tracks. From here we hiked around the hill to the intersection with the former Forest Service Road #192B. We followed this road for about a mile until we branched out on the short cut to Woodbury Trailhead. The short cut is a former FS Road and shown on Carlson's map. It is marked with a post and sign declaring "No Motor Vehicle Access". From this point we could make out the Woodbury Trailhead and our Jeep in the distance.
All in all, the hike measured 6.5 miles and took us 4 1/4 hours. We probably could have done it in 3 1/2 hours without as much water and our misdirection around the lower mine.
Gate Policy: If a gate is closed upon arrival, leave it closed after you go through. If it is open, leave it open. Leaving a closed gate open may put cattle in danger. Closing an open gate may cut them off from water. Please be respectful, leave gates as found.
WARNING! Hiking and outdoor related sports can be dangerous. Be responsible and prepare for the trip. Study the area you are entering and plan accordingly. Dress for the current and unexpected weather changes. Take plenty of water. Never go alone. Make an itinerary with your plan(s), route(s), destination(s) and expected return time. Give your itinerary to trusted family and/or friends.