I've decided. It's Spoke & Wheel hands down. Most likely they win 1st, 2nd, and 3rd.
They don't just have 1 great burger, they have at least 3.
We rode the double bike (me and Noel, not Bob) last night so we could get happy hour pricing on drinks and apps. Got the Bacon Truffle Burger.
I've had all three of these and can't tell which I even like better:
SPOKE AND WHEEL BURGER
caramelized onions, jalapeños, cheddar, sweet
potato, arugula, sweet chili sauce
ORIGINAL HATCH GREEN CHILI BURGER
honey, hatch green chili, pico de gallo, queso
anejo enchilado (mexican feta style cheese)
BACON TRUFFLE BURGER
lettuce, tomato, smoked bacon, white truffle
oil, provolone, balsamic syrup
---------------------------------
A few more excerpts:
Windsor is a great burger but it is hit or miss. Every S&W burger kicks its butt. And Windsor also loses to S&W's laid back atmosphere.
Humble Pie's used to be high for me but hit or miss as well. Sourdough burger with added avocado and bacon.
Habit burgers are good for the price. Not disappointing.
Pier 54 - I was impressed with how well this $10 southwestern burger tasted. I've never had a pepper on a burger that flavorful. The meat was peppered very well. Bacon was a bonus.
Mim's - I've changed my mind. I like the place, but the last two times were not impressive at all and the onion rings were crap. Makes me sad. Still a good place to meet and eat for airport levee hangouts.
BurgerFi in Mesa was a quandary. They have burger in their name yet only have 2 burgers on the menu (we'll never count veg "burgers" on this list) and they weren't anything special at all. I see from their website they have a secret menu with other burgers now but that's as silly a calling beans a burger.
Maize's - signature burger. Just plain ok. Not something to get again.
Original Wineburger - I would definitely go there again. I got their signature burger with added bacon. The meat was really good. A lot of places forget that part somehow and just add stuff on to create flavor.
*The fries were awesome too. Beer battered and peppered.
Burger House in Globe -Yelp said 16 reviews = 4.5 stars. I got the signature burger. It was no more than a high school cafeteria burger.