OK, so I encountered this again last weekend and finally decided to ask if somebody here knows the "rules".
I'm a big fan of a well-maintained trail, especially when the FS gets out there and cuts the trees which have fallen across the trail. This is good because it makes it easier to hike (rather than climbing over a 3-foot diameter log), and its environmentally friendly because it prevents hikers from establishing a new trail over or around the obstacle, damaging surrounding plants, and usually causing erosion or runoff issues.
So the question is this ... I see plenty of beautifully cut trees. And yet these occur in Wilderness Areas. The ones where no mechanized equipment can be used. So does the FS actually hike out there with chainsaws and maintain the trail under cover of darkness, or am I supposed to believe that two guys go out there with an old-school hand-saw and spend a few hours going back-and-forth to saw through the log? That seems positively ridiculous.
I'm not sure what my spirit animal is, but I'm confident it has rabies.
I've seen them with hand saws and axes on Humphreys Trail. Chain saws leave small wood shavings compared to the saw dust left by hand saws. You can tell the difference if the cut is recent.
chumley wrote:so I encountered this again last weekend
Yea, me too in from the Pine TH on the Pine Canyon TR#26. I have always assumed they use both hand saws and chain saws with certain guidelines applying depending on the wetness/dryness of the area to be maintenanced .
I know you can not use a chain saw in fighting a fire in a Wilderness area..... Got that info first hand from fire fighter trainers.....
Dawn
--On the loose to climb a mountain, on the loose where I am free. On the loose to live my life the way I think my life should be...For we only have a moment and a whole world yet to see...I'll be looking for tomorrow on the loose. ---unknown--
I had a close buddy who was a wilderness firefighter who maintained trails in the off season. They DID use misery whips and other hand tools to fell/clear even very large trees - going as far as hiking that stuff in and out of areas more than 20 miles from the nearest road access (he mostly worked in Montana). He had a video of he and another fire fighter removing a tree while it was on fire. It was pretty incredible. Of course, he was a sexy beast from all that hard work and bounded about on the trail in a way that made me feel like a lead balloon with chains on my feet.
Good thing I'm not into goody two-shoes
----------------------------------- Change will not come if we wait for some other person or some other time. We are the ones we've been waiting for. We are the change that we seek.- Barack Obama
Hike Arizona it is full of sharp, pointy, ankle-twisting, HAZmaster crushing ROCKS!!
Hike Arizona it is full of sharp, pointy, shin-stabbing, skin-shredding plants!
Hike Arizona it is full of striking, biting, stabbing, venomous wildlife!
All I know is Arizona is no chainsaws at least for the fighting of the wildfires. Like the Willow fire they had to wait till it got to none wilderness before they could bring on the equipment (my sister worked that fire for dispatch and confirmed the rules for me at least for AZ wildfires) ..... And there is a certain guideline for wildernesses but each Wilderness areas can adapt to their areas.... wilderness.net has general guide lines but sends you to each individual wilderness for special instructions like on how many a group can be in that area as well as how long can camp out in each wilderness....
Dawn
--On the loose to climb a mountain, on the loose where I am free. On the loose to live my life the way I think my life should be...For we only have a moment and a whole world yet to see...I'll be looking for tomorrow on the loose. ---unknown--
A chain saw in a wilderness would be bad ju ju. It is possible, if the managing agency does a mini environmental assessment or the like, but pretty unlikely. I'm told if there is a fire going on they can use certain mechanized equipment, but don't have that authoritatively. More likely there are volunteers or paid crews in there with saws and lopers. The volunteer community is smaller than the hiking community, but there are people crazy enough to do it.
Shawn
The bear went over the mountain to see what he could see.
Sredfield wrote:More likely there are volunteers or paid crews in there with saws and lopers. The volunteer community is smaller than the hiking community, but there are people crazy enough to do it.
I know a small group of people that go out regularly in the Catalinas and use cross-cut saws on the trails there. I had an interesting encounter in the Mazatzals this April: (excerpt from my website)
"I checked out Windsor Seep and found a couple of small pools. At the junction, there was a backpack hung in a tree, but no one answered when I called hello. I took a snack break and noticed a saw and some branch trimmers. The owner had not come back by the time I was done with my break, so I left a note thanking them for doing trailwork out here. I continued on to traverse the slopes of Mazatzal Peak. The views to the west were spectacular and I saw a lake in the distance. This is my first time in this part of the state and the geology here is incredible. I came upon the owner of the backpack and told him about the note I left for him. I said that I was out here hiking the Arizona Trail. “You must be Sirena” he said, “I used to follow your hike last year, but I haven’t checked it in a while.” Crazy. Out in the middle of nowhere. I asked him what his name was and he said I could call him the Lone Stranger. Okay…as we talked, it came out that the reason he wished to remain anonymous is that he was out here using a chainsaw to cut all the downed trees. He had left the hand tools as decoys. You may think, what’s wrong with that? All this time I’ve been talking about how bad the trail is and how there are downed trees all over the bad parts of the trail up ahead. Wouldn’t it be good to get rid of them? Well, since the Mazatzal is a wilderness, no chainsaws are allowed. All trees must be cut with a cross-cut saw powered by two people and sweat. He had stashed the chainsaw when he saw me come up on the trail, and he was happy to see that I was not a forest ranger. I had a nice visit with the Lone Stranger, who did finally tell me his name, but I’ll never tell. (when I later told my mother about this meeting, she was horrified that I had met some guy in the middle of nowhere that knew who I was that had a chainsaw and wouldn’t tell me his name)"
sirena wrote: (when I later told my mother about this meeting, she was horrified that I had met some guy in the middle of nowhere that knew who I was that had a chainsaw and wouldn’t tell me his name)"
Those are the things which terrify my mother as well. Convincing her that's it not those guys but the ones who travel in groups and would rather chop down a living tree for wood for their bonfire before they'd do an ounce of trail maintenance is just not worth the breath. Sounds like a perfectly wonderful encounter!
----------------------------------- Change will not come if we wait for some other person or some other time. We are the ones we've been waiting for. We are the change that we seek.- Barack Obama
Route Editor
Route Scout
.
](./images/smilies/eusa_wall.gif "Brick wall"){kind=small}
