username
X
password
register
for free!
help
ArticlesGuidesRoutes
 
Photosets
 
 Comments
triplogs   photosets   labels comments more
McFadden Horse Trail #146 - 18 members in 40 triplogs have rated this an average 4 ( 1 to 5 best )
1, 2  Next
40 triplogs
login for filter options
Oct 15 2023
avatar

 Routes 386
 Photos 49
 Triplogs 792

43 female
 Joined Jun 23 2015
 Phoenix, AZ
McFadden Horse Trail #146Globe, AZ
Globe, AZ
Hiking avatar Oct 15 2023
emilystardustTriplogs 792
Hiking8.35 Miles 2,362 AEG
Hiking8.35 Miles   6 Hrs   25 Mns   1.47 mph
2,362 ft AEG      44 Mns Break
 
1st trip
Partners none no partners
Route Scout Route Recorded  on Route Scout | Pop | Map | Popup | MapDEX
Dragging a bit today after Humphreys yesterday but we got in most of what we set out to do. Arch was definitely highlight as mentioned below. Off trail from scenic lookout to arch was a little better than I thought it’d be. Lone donkey on the road when we started and finished.
_____________________
 
Sep 24 2023
avatar

 Guides 107
 Routes 249
 Photos 2,067
 Triplogs 514

male
 Joined Nov 18 2005
 Phoenix, AZ
Cienega Spring Trail #145Globe, AZ
Globe, AZ
Hiking avatar Sep 24 2023
nonotTriplogs 514
Hiking18.00 Miles 4,000 AEG
Hiking18.00 Miles
4,000 ft AEG
 no routesno photosets
1st trip
Spent an enjoyable weekend in the Sierra Anchas.

Cienega trail is a good warmup before the climb up to McFadden Horse Mountain. I enjoyed the prime pine forest up top and wandered all the way to the overlook. Unfortunately a great deal of fog and low hanging clouds disrupted the scenic view. I spent time wondering whether the Native Americans that lived in the fort had any fear of heights.

Nobody seems to report the number of easily accessible/explorable mines along the Cienega trail. I peeked into a few but they all looked very mazelike, and a few had collapsed areas, so I didn't explore very far.

The McFadden Horse Mountain trail appears to get so little use that there is no discernable trail up top on the forest floor, but the Forest service appears to have constructed hundreds of cairns to try to keep you on track. While I thought at first the cairns were excessive, I still managed to lose the trail several times, usually where fallen trees had covered the cairns, so I appreciated all the effort they had put in.

The next day I headed up Reynold's creek and summited Center mountain and did a good deal of the way down the other side towards Lucky Strike, but turned around due to time concerns before reaching the intersection. I also wandered to the Dry Tank near the top of the mountain, and true to name, it was basically dry except a little mud in the middle.

On the way back I took the "other" Center mountain trail back to the Reynold's Creek trail. Both Center Mountain trail options have drawbacks. The lower trail is significantly overgrown. The upper trail is eroding and has several enormous fallen trees that completely block the trail. I can't recall both limboing while doing a monkey bar traverse before, but that is what it took to get through one section.

More flowers were observed along Reynold's creek trail than others.
wildflower observationwildflower observationwildflower observationwildflower observationwildflower observation
Wildflowers Observation Light

water 1 out of 5water 2 out of 5water less than maxwater less than max Cienega Spring Quart per minute Quart per minute
Maybe 2 liters per minute. The hose to the tank appears clogged but the tank itself had a bit of water in it, and the entire ground around was soaked. The spring cistern at the source was overflowing.

water 1 out of 5water less than maxwater less than maxwater less than max Reynolds Creek Falls - Sierra Ancha Pools to trickle Pools to trickle
A trickle flowing over the falls. Below the falls there were a few stagnant pools as the water appeared to go underground.

water 1 out of 5water 2 out of 5water less than maxwater less than max The Switchbacks Spring Quart per minute Quart per minute
A slight flow was observed in the creekbed. Maybe a liter per minute.
_____________________
http://hikearizona.com/garmin_maps.php

Hike Arizona it is full of sharp, pointy, ankle-twisting, HAZmaster crushing ROCKS!!
Hike Arizona it is full of sharp, pointy, shin-stabbing, skin-shredding plants!
Hike Arizona it is full of striking, biting, stabbing, venomous wildlife!
  1 archive
May 01 2023
avatar

 Guides 41
 Routes 1,626
 Photos 14,983
 Triplogs 2,760

69 male
 Joined Jan 20 2009
 Far NE Phoenix,
McFadden Duo and Elephant Rock Arch, AZ 
McFadden Duo and Elephant Rock Arch, AZ
 
Hiking avatar May 01 2023
The_EagleTriplogs 2,760
Hiking11.96 Miles 3,180 AEG
Hiking11.96 Miles   7 Hrs   14 Mns   1.98 mph
3,180 ft AEG   1 Hour   11 Mns Break14 LBS Pack
 
1st trip
Route Scout Route Recorded  on Route Scout | Pop | Map | Popup | MapDEX
Linda was up for an adventure in the Ancha. If this place was not so far from home, I'd spend a lot more time out here. But so would everyone else.

My plans were to do a CCW loop. McFadden Horse Mountain #146 > to the overlook up top > drop down to hit Elephant Rock Arch then off trail it to 288. After this hit McFadden Peak and complete the loop using McFadden Park Trail #55.

We parked in the pullout. All the Maps I've seen, call this Cienega Spring Trail #145. The sign at the TH call this #146 McFadden Horse Trail. Cienega Spring Trail does not join in and split off, until farther up. Not sure which is correct.

Branches and forest litter have been placed across the beginning to keep the Quads off the trail.
This trail gets your heart beating right out of the gate climbing 1900' to the McFadden Horse Mountain Peak. After this it trends slightly down, heading north towards the overlook and out to our drop in point. There's quite a bit of deadfall on this trail that is easily bypassed.

Loaded with a GPS track from @joebartels and @Bifrost, we checked out all our choices to drop in and finally settled on one we were both comfortable with. We found a steep loose chute and let the butt scoot begin.

We ultimately made our way over to the promised highlight of the day, Elephant Rock Arch, and enjoyed a break and some lunch. I never get tired of the geology in the Ancha. The route back over to SR288 is all off trail and can be slow going.

Next, up to the McFadden Lookout. Nobody was home and it was all locked up, so we took a break in the shade and enjoyed a snack.

I still have a bit of a lung funk going on, so Linda agreed that it's be ok to walk the road back in lieu of completing the loop on McFadden Park Trail #55. This cut off a couple of miles and some elevation gain at the end.

Pretty nice weather all day. Breezes kept in descent.

Good times in the Ancha. Good hiking with you again Linda.

water 1 out of 5water less than maxwater less than maxwater less than max McFadden Horse Mtn Gully (lower) Pools to trickle Pools to trickle
_____________________
There is a very fine line between "hobby" and "mental illness."
Dave Barry 🦅
  2 archives
May 01 2023
avatar

 Guides 110
 Routes 2,246
 Photos 8,982
 Triplogs 2,600

45 female
 Joined Dec 24 2007
 Ahwatukee, AZ
McFadden Duo and Elephant Rock Arch, AZ 
McFadden Duo and Elephant Rock Arch, AZ
 
Hiking avatar May 01 2023
LindaAnnTriplogs 2,600
Hiking11.01 Miles 3,101 AEG
Hiking11.01 Miles   7 Hrs   14 Mns   1.87 mph
3,101 ft AEG   1 Hour   21 Mns Break
 
1st trip
Route Scout Route Recorded  on Route Scout | Pop | Map | Popup | MapDEX
Bruce suggested a hike out in the Sierra Ancha. I like that range, so I was game. Got started a little after 0800 and headed up McFadden Horse Trail. The trail obviously doesn’t get much use, and there’s some deadfall, but fairly easy hiking and cairns keep you on track. My legs were tired from the start, which kind of sucked, but I tried to keep the whining to a minimum.

At the top, we went over to what appeared to be the high point, looked around, and had a snack. Cool temps, and a nice breeze. After that, we headed north along the ridge, which had great views, until we reached the end and had to drop down. This was a bit of an unknown, but we had Joe & Karl’s track from many years ago. After some trial and error, we scrambled down through the top cliff band, making sure not to descend anything we couldn’t climb back up if we had to turn around.

After that, it was a very steep descent down a chute. Lots of loose rock, dried leaves, and dirt. I think that was the longest butt scoot I’ve ever done. Amazingly, my brand new leggings were still intact a couple hundred feet later. It was impossible to avoid sending rocks down the chute, so Bruce would descend until he found a good rock or tree to hide behind, then I would descend to the same point. We did that a few times until we made it down and began traversing across to the arch.

The arch was the highlight of the loop, with amazing geology and views. We had lunch in the shade of the arch and enjoyed the breeze. After that, we headed down and over to the road. All off trail, with some scratchy vegetation in places, but overall straightforward. Bruce stirred up one rattlesnake not long before reaching the road. Lots of old bear scat, saw one deer.

After that, it was a sunny but breezy road walk up to McFadden Peak. Looked around the summit a bit, and then decided to take the road straight back to the car rather than looping around to the west. The idea of having to gain a few hundred feet right at the end of the hike via the planned loop was not appealing to either of us at that moment, and the road seemed like an easy way to finish out the hike. So it was an easy (but dusty) final few miles to the day.

Fun to see some new territory and hike with Bruce. Thanks for driving!
_____________________
Stop crying and just go do the hike.
 
Oct 09 2022
avatar

 Triplogs 12

female
 Joined Feb 06 2022
 Mesa, AZ
McFadden Horse Trail #146Globe, AZ
Globe, AZ
Hiking avatar Oct 09 2022
MikkiDTriplogs 12
Hiking10.84 Miles 2,548 AEG
Hiking10.84 Miles   6 Hrs   48 Mns   2.00 mph
2,548 ft AEG   1 Hour   23 Mns Break
 
no photosets
1st trip
Linked   none no linked trail guides
Partners none no partners
Route Scout Route Recorded  on Route Scout | Pop | Map | Popup | MapDEX
A day in the Sierra Anchas is a day well spent. After lots of wandering around, I couldn’t find the summit register at the coordinates provided, but maybe I’ll uncover it on a return trip. The views at the end of the trail were incredible- namely the crumbling walls of the ruins perched up so high above the canyons and drainages below. Great spot to stop and eat lunch. My GPS was on the fritz, so I had to stick with just following the Cairns and trusting my gut- which I somehow lost a few different times on my way down to cross the drainage after reaching the summit, but found them again when I got up on the eastern side of the mountain. When I was leaving, it was much easier to keep track of them 😅
 
Jun 11 2022
avatar

 Routes 18
 Photos 79
 Triplogs 23

female
 Joined Apr 28 2018
 Chandler, AZ
McFadden Horse Trail #146Globe, AZ
Globe, AZ
Hiking avatar Jun 11 2022
TboneKathyTriplogs 23
Hiking8.64 Miles 2,329 AEG
Hiking8.64 Miles   5 Hrs   42 Mns   1.81 mph
2,329 ft AEG      55 Mns Break
 
1st trip
Linked   linked  
Partners partners
John10s
Route Scout Route Recorded  on Route Scout | Pop | Map | Popup | MapDEX
McFadden Horse Trail was indeed steep. The first part of the trail was an old jeep road, so I figured steep would have limits. It did: upper limits! And where the eroded gullies left sloped road edges, there were horizontal slopes in addition to the vertical slope! Views were good, however, and I’m not saying that the difficulty rating was in error.

Reaching the top, the ponderosa pine forest was a great reward, and after a quick side trip to the high point, views got really spectacular with cliffs and Elephant Rock.

I don’t remember flies and gnats during this part of the hike. Maybe the views were just that good. Or maybe I’m getting used to flies this time of year, especially on this hike when they seemed more attracted to @john10s for a change. At least on the first half of the hike...

It was great to linger at the point and ponder the many unanswered questions Elephant Rock brings to mind. But we eventually began retracing our steps with our next goal being Elephant Rock Arch.

The farther we ventured back into the ponderosa pine forest, the worse the flies became. These weren’t just any flies. I didn’t spend much time looking at them intentionally, but they were probably at least four times as big as houseflies and had a dull green face. When they started biting (only me), I couldn’t ignore them any longer. They were oddly intent on biting just one of my upper arms. Close to being driven to distraction, and with plenty of forest left, I stopped to dig out and don my long-sleeved shirt and gloves. Relief. Until one painfully bit through a glove. Luckily it happened only once.

My best guess is that we’d encountered some type of horsefly. Sorry, entomologists, but I wasn’t honoring them with photos.

Out of the forest and down the switchbacks, the flies let up. We could enjoy the algal stromatolites when we got to that area, and even linger long enough for my search image to develop. Then I could spot them even embedded in the road with only their top surface exposed, with telltale concentric rings.

We drove to the trailhead for Elephant Rock Arch. With the lack of trail and just enough undergrowth, it soon became apparent that we wouldn’t have enough time to reach Elephant Rock Arch. I cast my vote for stopping at the steep valley. I found some information online about that valley. It has slopes of even 24%. I could have sworn it rivaled Half Dome’s 45%!
 Geology
 Geology [ checklist ]
[ checklist ]  Stromatolites
 
Jun 11 2022
avatar

 Guides 25
 Routes 376
 Photos 5,897
 Triplogs 346

40 male
 Joined Mar 01 2018
 Chandler, AZ
McFadden Horse Trail #146Globe, AZ
Globe, AZ
Hiking avatar Jun 11 2022
John10sTriplogs 346
Hiking8.64 Miles 2,329 AEG
Hiking8.64 Miles   5 Hrs   30 Mns   2.11 mph
2,329 ft AEG   1 Hour   24 Mns Break
 
1st trip
Linked   linked  
Partners partners
TboneKathy
Route Scout Route Recorded  on Route Scout | Pop | Map | Popup | MapDEX
With record heat at the lower elevations, we headed for higher elevations again this weekend. We hiked Hell's Hole two weeks ago and went a little farther north along Highway 288 this time to check out McFadden Horse Trail and Elephant Rock. The first two miles were a consistent uphill climb, a combination of jeep road and then a switchbacking trail beyond the intersection with Cienega Trail #145.

It was a humid morning with very still air, and the flies were relentless, which made the early part of the hike a little less enjoyable. The views got better and better as we gained elevation, but it was hard to fully appreciate the surroundings with the swarming bugs...the soundtrack of the hike was a concert of buzzing at different volumes and pitches from the various sizes and types of flies constantly in our faces. Luckily, things got a little better once the trail leveled off on top of McFadden Horse Mountain...fewer flies, and there was more shade among the ponderosas once we were out of the burn area.

We took a short detour over to the McFadden Horse high point at 7,510'. It was only 500 feet off the trail but is a fairly anticlimactic "peak"...it essentially a gentle ridge that was barely discernable as the high point, though it did offer a nice view of Four Peaks between the trees. Back on the trail, the stretch along the east rim of the mountain offered the best views of the day, overlooking the Cherry Creek area with the classic Sierra Ancha red cliffs and the gray spires and formations below. Some scattered thunderheads in the distance added a nice touch to the landscape.

Elephant Rock Fortress is an impressive overlook with incredible views, and the ruins on the island of white rock are intriguing. I couldn't see any land bridge connecting the ridge and the island...either something has eroded since the natives built structures there, or they were very courageous and skilled climbers. Given the location, it was probably a Salado lookout...I can't help but wonder how long it's been since someone has set foot set foot on top of that rock and gotten a close look at the structures.

[ youtube video ]

After some scrambling around on the rocks and a short break at the overlook, we started back, and the flies got more aggressive on the way out. On the flat stretches among the pine trees, the swarms were worse than ever and the flies were starting to bite...for a mile or two, it seemed like I had 5-10 around my face most of the time. Fortunately, they let up a little once we got out of the forest and started descending the last two miles. Near the Cienega #145 intersection, we noticed a lot of nice examples of stromatolites that we'd missed on the way in.

We didn't see anyone during the hike, and it was a warm but comfortable day aside from the morning humidity...and very enjoyable other than the aggressive flies. We had a little extra time after McFadden and drove further up 288 and hiked part of the Elephant Rock Arch route but didn't have time to get all the way there, so we'll have to come back and finish that one off another day.
 Flora
 Flora [ checklist ]
[ checklist ]  Prickly Pear
 Fauna
 Fauna [ checklist ]
[ checklist ]  Grasshopper
 Geology
 Geology [ checklist ]
[ checklist ]  Stromatolites
 
Jun 08 2022
avatar

 Guides 44
 Routes 162
 Photos 24,766
 Triplogs 2,411

75 male
 Joined May 04 2004
 Mesa, AZ
Cienega #145 McFadden Horse #146, AZ 
Cienega #145 McFadden Horse #146, AZ
 
Hiking avatar Jun 08 2022
CannondaleKidTriplogs 2,411
Hiking8.10 Miles 2,416 AEG
Hiking8.10 Miles   4 Hrs   45 Mns   1.80 mph
2,416 ft AEG      15 Mns Break20 LBS Pack
 no routes
1st trip
Partners partners
trixiec
Hike #4 of 4 from our Sierra Ancha 2022 camping/hiking trip.

The original plan before our trip was to hike the McFadden Horse Trail all the way to Elephant Rock overlook as we did 6 years ago.

However, since we had just pulled up stakes from our camp up at Billy Lawrence we figured we'd just stop at the Cienega Trail/Forest Road #145 intersection and hike the same route we last hiked just a week shy of 7 years ago. With the added distance from Cienega we decided to skip the trip out to Elephant Rock and just hit summit and return.

Of course, by following this route along FR #145 (which is now open to vehicular travel again) we would get another chance to visit the uranium mines along the way. Looking at my photos from 7 years ago very little of the mines has changed, the most notable being only one piece left of the original half-dozen rusted corrugated metal sheets which had been covering the largest of the mine entrances.

As usual, Tracey waited outside while I went in solo. Just inside a couple adits I was greeted by the sound of what appeared to be a swarm bees but was just a bunch of flies, which thankfully just moved away without bothering me. Being almost scrupulously clean there really wasn't anything worthy to highlight other than my EMF meter sounding a warning at the entrance to one mine.
(In later research , as long as one did not spend days and days in the same location the milliGauss readings were not high enough for any long-term danger... I hope)

Moving on...
Now on McFadden Horse Trail we began the slog to the top. After while on the ascent Tracey wondered aloud why there weren't any switch-backs... only for a few to appear, not that it made things much easier. But no matter, soon it eased off and we were in the shade for most of the way to the summit. We found a nice viewpoint just west of the summit with a nice view of Jack Mountain as well as the more distant Boneyback and Greenback peaks. With shade, a scenic view and a breeze we had the perfect lunch spot.

On the return trip we stopped by the only mine we had missed on the way up... how we missed it was a mystery to both of us as it was actually the largest, where the corrugated sheets used to be.

Back to the trailhead Tracey wandered over to the Cienega Creek water tank to rinse her out her neckerchief and called over for me to "check this out!" and sure enough it was worthy of another 100 foot walk to get a few photos of three spotted toads hanging around the tank. One was perched on the pipe Tracey had just rinsed her neckerchief in the water running from it without disturbing the toad.

And that wraps up our 2022 trip into the Sierra Ancha.

At four years since our last camping trip in the Sierra Ancha we both felt it had been too long so hopefully we won't wait that long again, but at a time a bit cooler than this trip... it was getting into the warm end for Tracey, but for me, heck I'm out in the triple digits almost every day. As long as the humidity single-digits/teens with a breeze and I'm wearing wicking gear from head-to-toe and keep everything damp it's all good.
 Fauna
 Fauna [ checklist ]
[ checklist ]  Red Spotted Toad
_____________________
CannondaleKid
 
Nov 19 2021
avatar

 Guides 8
 Routes 10
 Photos 1,028
 Triplogs 40

44 male
 Joined Jun 14 2019
 nomadic
McFadden Horse Mtn Elephant Rock Arch loop, AZ 
McFadden Horse Mtn Elephant Rock Arch loop, AZ
 
Hiking avatar Nov 19 2021
eruTriplogs 40
Hiking9.00 Miles
Hiking9.00 Miles   9 Hrs   30 Mns   0.95 mph
 
1st trip
A nice all day hike (to be able to soak the cool spots in), and much better counterclockwise than clockwise IMO.

Parking area is easy to find, and the jeep road leading up from it was well graded with some nice views. More tire tracks on it than boot prints. A faded sign is at the junction of the horse trail, which I found easier to follow than anticipated. It gets a bit steep and a little loose in places, and had one significant deadfall we had to route around. I was able to clear about 2/3 to 3/4 of the deadfall impacting the trail on the way up due to the lack of density in them, which was kind of fun. It gradually more forested as you climb, and the cairns increase in frequency.

The plateau of the peak itself I really enjoyed - a really nice mix of agave, grass, and scattered trees gave it a fascinating ambience. Very few cacti. The trail does become a bit hard to follow once you're past the "peak" (we hopped over to find a USGS marker or register and were unsuccessful) but gains clarity once you're on the ridge where the terrain is obviously constrained. Other than that brief section the cairns were more an affirmation I was on the right route vs something I was searching for in order to navigate. Didn't see any boot prints, but some hooves have been on the trail recently, and we saw both cow and deer up on the plateau.

The scenic point at the end of the trail was a great place to stop for lunch, and well worth exploring. A few minutes before it there's some pillars off to the east visible from trail, and an obvious break in foliage to drop down and see them - well worth visiting.

We backtracked and looked for a way to connect to elephant rock arch - a direct route failed, but topo looked friendlier at a nearby gully/canyon and we found a cow path that took us to an easy if slow traverse across the side of the plateau we were on top of earlier. Some really cool multi-colored scooped out rocks that probably haven't been seen by too many people recently near the arch.

We ended up above the arch, looking down on the top of it hah. A really neat spot, we lingered there, dropped around the eastern side of the arch and onto where most people probably go, then wandered around there onto the little point north of it.

The hike back to 288 was pretty straightforward off-trail, we hit the road 10 minutes before sunset and had a simple hike down the road to our vehicle at the #146 TH with amazing views of the sunset (whilst snacking on BBQ chips). The puffies we wore in the morning came in handy on that walk down. :)

More detailed route info on the arch & connector guides as they were written from this trip. :p
 Geology
 Geology [ checklist ]
[ checklist ]  Troy Quartzite
 Culture
 Culture [ checklist ]
[ checklist ]  Camp-fire  HAZ Food
 Meteorology
 Meteorology [ checklist ]
[ checklist ]  Sunset
foliage observationfoliage observationfoliage observationfoliage observationfoliage observation
Autumn Foliage Observation Isolated
wildflower observationwildflower observationwildflower observationwildflower observationwildflower observation
Wildflowers Observation Isolated

water 1 out of 5water less than maxwater less than maxwater less than max McFadden Horse Mtn Gully Pools to trickle Pools to trickle
Single murky pool.

water 1 out of 5water less than maxwater less than maxwater less than max McFadden Horse Mtn Gully (lower) Pools to trickle Pools to trickle
Multiple murky pools, much bovine interaction.
  3 archives
Apr 24 2021
avatar

 Guides 99
 Routes 1,484
 Photos 16,072
 Triplogs 1,374

male
 Joined Jan 07 2017
 Fountain Hills,
Horsing Around in the Sierra Ancha, AZ 
Horsing Around in the Sierra Ancha, AZ
 
Hiking avatar Apr 24 2021
DixieFlyerTriplogs 1,374
Hiking10.20 Miles 2,897 AEG
Hiking10.20 Miles
2,897 ft AEG
 
I decided to go horsing around in the Sierra Ancha Wilderness yesterday, and what better place to horse around than McFadden Horse Mountain!

I first did an out-and-back hike by taking the McFadden Horse Mountain Trail all the way to its end at a scenic overlook. Along the way I went off trail for a short distance to the McFadden Horse Mountain Highpoint.

There had been some trail maintenance done since I was out there a year ago -- there is no more deadfall on the trail from the TH to the McFadden Horse Trail-Cienega Spring Trail Junction. There were 3-4 downed trees on the trail as I headed up the mountain, but the fallen trees were small ones that were very easy to step over. The trail is easy to follow and there are lots of large cairns along the trail.

Once on the top of the mountain, the trail is very delightful to hike on as there are hardly any rocks and you are walking on soft pine needles for the most part. Views at the summit are obstructed so there is not much to see. I do not believe that there is a benchmark disk at the summit.

The best part of the hike is from the summit to the overlook. There is some nice geology and great views at the overlook. I thought about trying to go from the overlook to Elephant Rock Arch, but decided against it as I wasn't sure how far I would have to descend to make my way over to the arch. I may go to the Arch from the other direction on a future hike, and explore getting from the arch to the overlook.

The descent down the mountain was nice because there were nice views of the Mazzies in front of you all the way down.

I enjoyed this hike and I will have to do it again.

On the way back to Phoenix we turned on FR 487 and hiked up to Aztec Peak. I started to drive all the way to the top, but decided to park a half mile or so before getting to the summit, and at least make a little bit of a hike out of it. It was a nice day and we enjoyed the views at the summit.

Mileage and elevation gain for the 2 hikes is below.
McFadden Horse Mountain: 8.7 miles; AEG of 2,602 feet
Aztec Peak: 1.5 miles; AEG of 295 feet

Stats above are the sum of the two
_____________________
Civilization is a nice place to visit but I wouldn't want to live there
 
May 01 2020
avatar

 Photos 11
 Triplogs 9

female
 Joined Jan 10 2018
 
McFadden Horse Trail #146Globe, AZ
Globe, AZ
Hiking avatar May 01 2020
outandbackTriplogs 9
Hiking8.25 Miles 2,184 AEG
Hiking8.25 Miles   6 Hrs      1.38 mph
2,184 ft AEG
 no routesno photosets
1st trip
Linked   none no linked trail guides
Partners none no partners
Haven't hiked this trail since before the Juniper fire in 2016, so I was curious to see how it was recovering and I guessed (correctly) that it would be remote enough for some 2020-style social distancing, too. It's in decent shape overall, but seemed worth leaving a report for future hikers. So, dear future hikers: Here's a report for you!

First: The trailhead parking area might be easy to miss. It's on the right side of 288, just before a sharp turn and just past a closed road on the left (Road is #2770 according to the map, but it's not signed as far as I noticed). There is a wooden sign at the base of the trail but you probably can't see it from the road, especially if you're looking for a big painted sign like for the other trailheads. But it's a decent sized parking area with room for several cars (although we had it all to ourselves this day).

Okay! We've parked. Now let's hike! The hike starts straight uphill on an old Jeep road (a.k.a. Cienega Trail). Note: Cienega Trail is outside the Wilderness boundary and there were some fairly fresh ATV tracks on that section, so it's good to be aware of that possibility. I've seen hunters along there, too, during hunting season. That portion of the trail is in decent shape and, despite some evidence of the recent fire, still has plenty of tree cover for shade. We saw some warblers (Grace's and Yellow-rumped), as well as Western bluebirds, and a wild turkey (watch out for hunting season, turkey!).

Once on #146 itself, however, the trail is a bit more eroded and rockier than I recall——although exactly as steep as I remember. :D The first mile or so above the junction was pretty heavily burned and the former shade trees are just dead snags now, so there's a lot of sun exposure. I was glad I had a hat. It's still pretty, though, with manzanita and scrub oak providing some green, and quite a few wildflowers blooming. And, of course, the views are more expansive now, so that's a benefit. There's quite a bit of deadfall on that mile+ of the trail, although it's easy enough to go over or around. Once up on top of the mountain, the trail levels off and there is very little evidence of fire and things are a lot easier. The tree cover is intact, so there's plenty of shade, and we saw lots of butterflies (Common Buckeye, Tiger Swallowtail, Arizona Sister), birds (mountain chickadees, juniper titmouse, white-breasted nuthatch, brown creeper, summer tanager, various woodpeckers) as well as one white-tailed deer and one mule deer——both does. Quite a lot of company up there!

The sections of trail going across the mountain top, down and up the ravine, and out along the ridge to the promontory were all in good shape. However this trail doesn't see much human traffic (which is great!), and the pine needle carpet is pretty resilient, so there's rarely a clear footpath to follow. Instead you need to either be great with a map and compass, or just follow the large and plentiful cairns, which are easy to spot and very reliable, although deadfall may obscure a stack here or there. Just do a little recon and you'll find them again. They're pretty close together, so you shouldn't have to look far.

The promontory made a great lunch spot, with the view of Elephant Rock and some Claret cup hedgehog cacti blooming for a bonus. I wished I'd brought a hammock to put up on the ridge for a post-lunch nap, but I didn't (such an amateur!), and we were on a bit of a schedule anyway, so we returned the way we came. I was very glad for trekking poles on the way back down, as the trail is steep, loose, and rocky——the trifecta of potential ankle injuries! But we had no incidents and thus were able to spend a little extra energy clearing some of the deadfall off the trail. (Much better than BEING the deadfall on the trail. :lol: )

The whole trip was about 6 hours at a fairly relaxed pace, with stops for bird-watching, plant IDs, and lunch. Bonus: we were the only people on the trail.
wildflower observationwildflower observationwildflower observationwildflower observationwildflower observation
Wildflowers Observation Moderate
Manzanita, Southwestern lewisia, fleabane, Indian paintbrush, claret cup hedgehog cacti, and others.
 
Apr 06 2020
avatar

 Guides 99
 Routes 1,484
 Photos 16,072
 Triplogs 1,374

male
 Joined Jan 07 2017
 Fountain Hills,
Horsing Around in the Sierra Ancha, AZ 
Horsing Around in the Sierra Ancha, AZ
 
Hiking avatar Apr 06 2020
DixieFlyerTriplogs 1,374
Hiking12.00 Miles 2,785 AEG
Hiking12.00 Miles
2,785 ft AEG
 
I was wanting to another hike that was compatible with social distancing, so I headed out to the Sierra Ancha, deep in the heart of @grasshopper and @Oregon_Hiker country! While there I bagged a couple of summits that I had not done before: McFadden Horse Mountain and Aztec Peak.

I first drove to the McFadden Trailhead, which is at mm 288 on Highway 288. Highway 288 is mostly paved but is part dirt road. The dirt portion is in great shape right now, and is actually better than some of the paved portions.

It is a steep climb up to McFadden Horse Mountain, but it is very nice once on top. I made my way over to the high point, and then returned the way that I came. I saw no other hikers on the trail.

I then drove to FR 487, and since the gate at the Falls CG was open, I drove to the Peterson TH and parked. Most any vehicle can drive to the Falls CG, and actually you could get to Workman Falls. However, there are a couple of sections beyond the Falls where you would need a high clearance 4WD vehicle to safely proceed. Once you get past the couple of rough spots, the road is in great shape and you could drive all the way up to the top of Aztec Peak if you wanted to.

My original intention was to do the Abbey Way's 151/FR 487 Loop, so I took FR 487 all the way to the summit of Aztec Peak. FR 487 has a smooth dirt surface, and it is very easy to hike on. Once at the summit, I walked a little way on Abbey's Way Trail #151, and I could see that the trail was going to be a bit rocky. I had also read triplogs that said the trail was very overgrown and that you'd be pushing through some thick, thorny vegetation in many places; thus, I decided that it would be best just to take 487 back to my vehicle, so that is what I did.

There are some nice views atop Aztec Peak, and I am glad that I finally went up there. I saw no other hikers on the hike, but on the way back about a mile from the summit I met a couple of trucks going up 487, and a few minutes later I met 6 RAZR's on their way to the summit. They all must have decided to hang around on the summit for a while, because they never passed me on my way back to the TH.

Mileage and elevation gain for the 2 hikes is below.
McFadden Horse Mountain: 5.5 miles with an AEG of 1,834'
Aztec Peak: 6.5 miles with an AEG of 951'

The stats above are the sum of these 2.
 Meteorology
 Meteorology [ checklist ]
[ checklist ]  Snow
wildflower observationwildflower observationwildflower observationwildflower observationwildflower observation
Wildflowers Observation None
There were no wildflowers to be seen on this hike. However, on the drive in on Highway 288, there were LOTS of wildflowers to be seen on the lower part of the road, especially globemallow, lupine, and desert marigold.
_____________________
Civilization is a nice place to visit but I wouldn't want to live there
  2 archives
Oct 16 2019
avatar

 Guides 99
 Routes 1,484
 Photos 16,072
 Triplogs 1,374

male
 Joined Jan 07 2017
 Fountain Hills,
The McFaddens & Elephant Rock Arch, AZ 
The McFaddens & Elephant Rock Arch, AZ
 
Hiking avatar Oct 16 2019
DixieFlyerTriplogs 1,374
Hiking9.30 Miles 2,685 AEG
Hiking9.30 Miles   6 Hrs   7 Mns   2.12 mph
2,685 ft AEG   1 Hour   44 Mns Break
 
1st trip
Partners partners
SecretMtnLover
I managed to convince Tracie, my favorite and intrepid hiking partner, to join me on a trip to the Sierra Anchas. The plan was to do 2 hikes: Hike #1 was to go to the McFadden Peak Summit via FR 561, and then when we got back to the TH we'd go up to Elephant Rock Arch; Hike #2 was to go to the summit of McFadden Horse Mountain.

Hike #1 went off without a hitch. The hike up to McFadden Peak on the forest road was basically a mini Mount Ord hike. There were some nice views at the summit and along the way up, but the hike wasn't terribly exciting. I really enjoyed being up on Elephant Rock Arch, although the hike there was slow going -- it was entirely off-trail, and there was quite a bit of vegetation to go around or through. I would definitely recommend a GPS track for the hike up to the arch -- there are several good tracks in the triplogs on this site.

The hike up to the arch took a bit longer and was more tiring than I expected, so we did not go all the way to the summit of McFadden Horse Mountain. Instead, we took the McFadden Horse Trail up to the junction with the Cienega Springs Trail and then turned around and went back to the TH. The TH was a small pullout on Highway 288 just across from mile marker 288. I plan to go back to the area before long and bag McFadden Horse Mountain and Aztec Peak.

Mileage and elevation gain above is the sum of the 2 hikes: The hike to McFadden Peak and Elephant Rock Arch was 7.3 miles with 2,025' of elevation gain; the hike up and down the portion of McFadden Horse Road was 2.0 miles with 660' of elevation gain.
 Culture
 Culture [ checklist ]
[ checklist ]  Reference Mark
foliage observationfoliage observationfoliage observationfoliage observationfoliage observation
Autumn Foliage Observation None
There was virtually no fall foliage to be seen -- there was a bit of sumac and a random leaf here and there. I imagine that it will be a week or 2 before much fall foliage is seen.
_____________________
Civilization is a nice place to visit but I wouldn't want to live there
  1 archive
Apr 29 2017
avatar

 Guides 6
 Routes 183
 Photos 5,612
 Triplogs 1,647

male
 Joined Mar 12 2004
 Scottsdale, AZ
McFadden Horse Trail #146Globe, AZ
Globe, AZ
Hiking avatar Apr 29 2017
John9LTriplogs 1,647
Hiking8.96 Miles 2,644 AEG
Hiking8.96 Miles
2,644 ft AEG
 no routesno photosets
1st trip
Linked   linked  
Partners partners
BrunoP
chumley
Headed out to the Sierra Ancha with Chumley and BrunoP. We planned on car camping and wanted to do a couple of hikes over the weekend. We made the drive up Saturday morning and started with McFadden Horse Mountain. I've seen pics of this one and thought it looked interesting. This turned out to be a solid hike with amazing views!

We parked off Hwy 288 and started the hardy climb up the Cienega Spring Trail. The old road climbs and climbs as you make your way through the forest. There are several large sections of burn. We continued on and connected onto the McFadden Horse Trail. This trail continues climbing through a burn section. With much effort we topped out and took a short break to water Bruno. Views were wonderful!

Once up top it's very easy going along the mostly flat mesa as you head through the unburnt forest following a series of large cairns. We both really enjoyed this section and cruised through as we wrapped around and headed north. The views are impressive as we arrived at the viewpoint for the hilltop ruin. It's recessed off McFadden and looks difficult to access. From scoping it out there is a route down on the left(west) side of the mesa. You then need to traverse and climb the NW corner. Looks very intriguing! Maybe another time.

After lunch we started our return and cruised back. Along the way we detoured to the high point but couldn't find a summit cairn. This mountain doesn't need one. From there we started our descent down the switchbacks. The trail is in good condition with minimal deadfall. It's easy going as long as you watch your step. In time we arrived back at the truck and headed out in search of a campsite.

This was a great hike that I'm glad we hit. It's quality hiking with solid views. The hilltop ruin looks very cool and I'd love to return to see it up close.
_____________________
  1 archive
Apr 29 2017
avatar

 Guides 94
 Routes 840
 Photos 22,055
 Triplogs 1,993

52 male
 Joined Sep 18 2002
 Tempe, AZ
McFadden Horse Trail #146Globe, AZ
Globe, AZ
Hiking avatar Apr 29 2017
chumleyTriplogs 1,993
Hiking8.96 Miles 2,644 AEG
Hiking8.96 Miles   4 Hrs   21 Mns   2.21 mph
2,644 ft AEG      18 Mns Break
 
1st trip
Linked   linked  
Partners partners
John9L
Karl told me we could see Elephant Rock Arch from this side. Well, maybe not.

Fire had taken its toll on the ascent, but the top of the mountain was either untouched or looked the way a managed burn should look with no crowning. We took the time to find the actual highpoint despite there being no benchmark. The summit area is quite flat and the highest point marked on the topo is not the highest when you're there. No sign of a cairn or anything to signify the high point either. Oh well.

The views off the rim are worth the price of admission. It's great up here.

On the descent it started snowing on us. I didn't believe it at first. It wasn't that cold. It had been 47 when we started and was 58 when we finished. I'd guess it was in the low 50s when the flurries hit. Probably the warmest I can recall for seeing falling snow. It was very light and only lasted a couple of minutes. Still cool.

Drove over to Aztec to see the falls and the summit. The tower is officially closed to visitors now with a nice fence and shiny new razor wire. Two day use sites were hosting large group campouts. If I had to guess, these are the people who will start the next fire.

water 1 out of 5water 2 out of 5water less than maxwater less than max Workman Creek Falls Light flow Light flow
water report recorded in the field on our app Route Scout
_____________________
I'm not sure what my spirit animal is, but I'm confident it has rabies.
 
Aug 24 2016
avatar

 Routes 36
 Photos 2,658
 Triplogs 1,347

67 male
 Joined Jul 28 2004
 Scottsdale, AZ
McFaddening, AZ 
McFaddening, AZ
 
Hiking avatar Aug 24 2016
mazatzalTriplogs 1,347
Hiking9.00 Miles 3,100 AEG
Hiking9.00 Miles   6 Hrs      1.80 mph
3,100 ft AEG   1 Hour    Break
 no routes
1st trip
Decided to check out a few new places :) First up was Haigler Creek from Fisherman's Point - great area. Looks like the creekside campground a bit further downstream is pretty nice too.

After Haigler I headed south through Young and hit McFadden Peak - nice short hike up the road to the lookout and a short detour down the Park McFadden trail.

Last up was McFadden Horse Mountain, just to the high point. Some light rain on the way back down the steep trail.
_____________________
  2 archives
Aug 12 2016
avatar

 Guides 2
 Photos 95
 Triplogs 20

35 male
 Joined Jul 08 2012
 Tucson, AZ
McFadden Horse Trail #146Globe, AZ
Globe, AZ
Hiking avatar Aug 12 2016
dieanotherday15Triplogs 20
Hiking8.25 Miles 2,184 AEG
Hiking8.25 Miles   5 Hrs      1.65 mph
2,184 ft AEG
 no routes
1st trip
Linked   none no linked trail guides
Partners none no partners
Today, I was finally able to hike the McFadden Horse Mountain Trail. I tried to hike it about a month ago, but upon reaching the trailhead I learned it was closed due to the Juniper Fire. I learned a valuable lesson about always checking whether a trail is open during the summer.

After the expiration of the closure order on July 31, I finally made it back to the Sierra Anchas today. I was eager to see what damage the fire had wrought on this area. If I'm not mistaken, the fire began not far from the trail. The first two miles of this trail show fire damage of varying intensity. The first half mile up to the saddle, the trees were lightly burned (if it all). At the saddle, burn damage becomes much more evident. Gazing out at the valley toward Aztec Peak, there is a huge swathe of forest that was obliterated by fire. The fire lightly burned the next half of the trail to the junction with the Cienega Spring Trail. Once you turn left on the McFadden Trail at this juncture, you begin a steep climb through a so-called moon crater of fire damage. The original scrub landscape of the hill is heavily burned and has seen some erosion. The trail is a little tricky during this section, but eventually you begin climbing into a part dead, partially burned trees until you reach the flat mountain top of McFadden Horse Mountain. From here, I was afraid the trail would be impossible to follow because of fire damage obliterating the cairned routes. Fortunately, the top of the mountain seems to have been untouched. The remainder of the trail until the scenic lookout is in good shape except for the occasional difficulty finding a cairn. When you reach the last half mile of the trail, you get a good view out at the Cherry Creek area. The mountainside you gaze at is heavily burned in areas and untouched in others. I suspect the Moody Ridge trail, which was a difficult trek to follow before the fire is probably impossible now. Fortunately, the mountain you are following was untouched by fire, as the rim seems to have prevent the fire from spreading.

Overall it was an excellent trek through one of Arizona's finest wildernesses!
wildflower observationwildflower observationwildflower observationwildflower observationwildflower observation
Wildflowers Observation Isolated
_____________________
 
Apr 15 2016
avatar

 Routes 1
 Photos 150
 Triplogs 35

58 male
 Joined Nov 03 2008
 QC AZ
McFadden Horse Trail #146Globe, AZ
Globe, AZ
Hiking avatar Apr 15 2016
Carioca43Triplogs 35
Hiking12.00 Miles 2,184 AEG
Hiking12.00 Miles
2,184 ft AEG
 no routes
Partners none no partners
It was good to get out on a backpacking trip again. I picked up a pretty serious bronchial infection in February and it really slowed me down.

I did this with my Scout Troop 838 We are prepping for a Grand Canyon Trip so we keep building miles and difficulty. I really love Elephant Rock so this fit the bill I had 3 adults and 12 kids.

The steep beat me up I was the last to make to camp on the top of the Mcfadden Horse MT. In the morning we got up early and booked it out to the Rock. I love the hike on top then to meet the spectacular views of the Cherry Creek Wilderness. Kids did pretty good I had some first timers that I actually beat out but the more experienced ones are learning and doing great. Will post photoset later, just trying to catch up on logs
_____________________
  4 archives
Sep 19 2015
avatar

 Guides 4
 Routes 491
 Photos 10,890
 Triplogs 1,257

55 male
 Joined Nov 20 2012
 Phoenix, AZ
McFadden Super Loop, AZ 
McFadden Super Loop, AZ
 
Hiking avatar Sep 19 2015
BiFrostTriplogs 1,257
Hiking20.48 Miles 4,391 AEG
Hiking20.48 Miles   10 Hrs   18 Mns   2.20 mph
4,391 ft AEG   1 Hour    Break
 no routes
1st trip
Joe put together a great loop that was derived from an earlier trip to Elephant Arch. We hiked up McFadden Horse Trail from Hwy 288 to get to the arch gaining 1600 feet right from the start. Once on top we had excellent views traversing out to the arch with this area definitely the highlight of the loop. Just the approach to the arch was half the fun negotiating the rocky cliffs and great views. We took a nice break at the arch before heading downhill and another traverse towards McFadden Peak.

On the road to McFadden Peak the views again were excellent and the tower was in good shape. Spent some time checking it out with birds eye view of the entire range. Coming off the top we picked up the Park McFadden Trail and followed this down several miles to Circle Ranch and Reynolds Creek area. Lots of shade on the way down with impressive stands of ponderosa and large oaks. We crossed Hwy 288 and headed up another road following Reynolds Creek for a few miles.

We finished off the day looping around to Cienega Spring which was nice surprise. The spring box was feed by a pipe with very clean looking water and cool meadow area. From there we followed Cienega Spring Trail to close the loop from where we started early in the morning.
 Geology
 Geology [ checklist ]
[ checklist ]  Natural Arch
_____________________
  2 archives
Sep 19 2015
avatar

 Guides 264
 Routes 2,797
 Photos 14,494
 Triplogs 5,894

55 male
 Joined Nov 20 1996
 
McFadden Super Loop, AZ 
McFadden Super Loop, AZ
 
Hiking avatar Sep 19 2015
joebartelsTriplogs 5,894
Hiking20.40 Miles 4,300 AEG
Hiking20.40 Miles   10 Hrs   18 Mns   2.19 mph
4,300 ft AEG   1 Hour    Break14 LBS Pack
 
1st trip
Redo of Bruce's masterpiece plus Cienega #145.

McFadden Horse Trail
Most will rate this lower due to the steep approach. The forest up top, eastern and Elephant Butte views win me over.

Elephant Rock Arch
Bridged the gap connecting McFadden to Elephant Rock. Shorts are fine, took under a half hour. We stopped above the arch then headed down. 1 class four downclimb. Ironically I climbed up it last time out of curiosity. I couldn't figure out the downclimb last time so I jumped 10? feet. Got the twist move on the first try this time then did it again for fun. Fairly certain you could backtrack a bit to avoid the obstacle.

McFadden Peak
Just a road walk up. Impressive views of the thick mogul berber carpet of pines.

Park McFadden Trail #55
Majority of this is an old road down to Circle Ranch. Without using Hank's track I would have missed where it leaves the road for awhile. The cairns at each end are faint and the trail is faint for that segment. Found a tank and added to the map. From Circle Ranch down it's a nice trail. The upper isn't bad but most would prefer the lower part.

Cienega Spring Trail #145
Just a road. A little closer and personal views such as from McFadden Peak.
 Fauna
 Fauna [ checklist ]
[ checklist ]  Teva
 Named place
 Named place [ checklist ]
[ checklist ]  Elephant Rock Arch - Sierra Ancha

water 1 out of 5water 2 out of 5water 3 out of 5water 4 out of 5 Cienega Spring Gallon + per minute Gallon + per minute
water report recorded in the field on our app Route Scout Super fresh clear

_____________________
- joe
 
average hiking speed 1.84 mph
1, 2  Next

WARNING! Hiking and outdoor related sports can be dangerous. Be responsible and prepare for the trip. Study the area you are entering and plan accordingly. Dress for the current and unexpected weather changes. Take plenty of water. Never go alone. Make an itinerary with your plan(s), route(s), destination(s) and expected return time. Give your itinerary to trusted family and/or friends.

helpcommentissue

end of page marker